voices hub
inside the story
voices hub
inside the story
Those lecturing Israel should walk a mile in a kibbutz
Brian Lilley
Political Columnist/Toronto Sun
Source
date
FORMAT
Toronto Sun
Jan 22, 2024
Article
topics
Middle East Context
Free Expression & Civil Discourse
Context
In this column, Brian Lilley reflects on visiting Israeli communities attacked on October 7, including Kibbutz Re’im and Kfar Aza. He describes walking through burned homes, speaking with members of local defence units, and observing evidence of close-quarters violence following the Hamas assault. The article contrasts reading about the attacks from afar with experiencing the destruction in person. Lilley references comments by Israeli officials and civilians who argue that external critics often underestimate the brutality of the events and the security concerns that followed. The piece situates these observations within broader international debate about Israel’s military response and diplomatic criticism.
Key Insight
The article argues that firsthand exposure to the aftermath of October 7 alters perceptions of the conflict. Lilley suggests that physical evidence of violence and survivor testimony shape how Israelis and visitors interpret subsequent military actions and international criticism.
Implications For Canadians
For Canadians, the piece highlights the gap between distant commentary and on-the-ground experience. Understanding how lived exposure influences threat perception can support more informed civic debate, particularly when Canadian officials or commentators assess foreign conflicts from afar.
Related Topics
Canadian Website Faces “Doxxing” Questions After Listing Jewish Groups...
Dean Baxendale
Feb 3, 2026
The Bureau
Free Expression & Civil Discourse
National Security & Geopolitics
In this op-ed, Dean Baxendale recounts travelling to Israel with Canadian journalists on an Exigent Foundation trip and attending briefings with Shurat HaDin. He examines security concerns raised after a Canadian website published databases identifying IDF volunteers, Jewish institutions, and participating journalists.
Trauma keeps its grip on northern Israel.
Karen Woods
Dec 15, 2025
National Post
Middle East Context
National Security & Geopolitics
In this on-the-ground analysis, Karen Woods reports from northern Israeli communities near the Lebanese border facing ongoing insecurity after Hezbollah attacks. Through interviews and site visits, she documents displacement, damaged homes, and the psychological strain of prolonged threat.
Seeing Israel through new eyes after week witnessing hope, determination
Corey Herscu
Dec 7, 2025
Toronto Sun
Middle East Context
Social Cohesion & Community Impact
In this reflective article, a Canadian participant recounts a week in Israel after October 7, visiting affected communities and meeting survivors. The piece emphasizes lived experience, resilience, and a more complex understanding of grief and civic solidarity.
Quarterly Analysis.
Canadian Focus.
Receive curated commentary and reporting from Exigent Voices—grounded in firsthand experience and delivered quarterly to your inbox.
