
voices hub
inside the story

voices hub
inside the story
The smell of horror in Israel’s kibbutzim is hardest to forget
Context
In this column, Rob Roberts recounts his visit to Kibbutz Re’im, Kfar Aza, Sderot, and the Nova music festival site following the October 7 Hamas attacks. Guided by emergency response volunteers, he walks through burned homes, bullet-marked walls, and rooms where residents were killed. The article describes signage marking where victims died and recounts testimony from local responders explaining what occurred during the assault. Roberts reflects on sensory impressions—particularly smell—as a powerful reminder of the violence. The piece combines field observation with commentary urging Canadian readers to confront the scale and brutality of the attacks firsthand rather than relying solely on distant reporting.
Key Insight
The article emphasizes the enduring psychological impact of October 7 on both survivors and visitors. Roberts argues that direct exposure to physical evidence of violence alters perception and underscores the severity of the attack beyond what written accounts alone convey.
Implications For Canadians
For Canadians, the piece highlights how distance from conflict shapes interpretation. Firsthand witnessing can influence how security threats are understood and debated domestically. The article encourages readers to consider how mediated narratives differ from on-the-ground realities when evaluating foreign policy and humanitarian responses.
Related Topics

The smell of horror in Israel’s kibbutzim is hardest to forget
Rob Roberts
Jan 23, 2024
National Post
Middle East Context
National Security & Geopolitics
In this column, Rob Roberts recounts visiting Kibbutz Re’im, Kfar Aza, Sderot, and the Nova festival site after the October 7 attacks. Guided by emergency responders, he reflects on evidence of the assault and urges Canadians to confront its scale firsthand.

Quarterly Analysis.
Canadian Focus.
Receive curated commentary and reporting from Exigent Voices—grounded in firsthand experience and delivered quarterly to your inbox.





